Councillors Critique Government Plan to Overhaul Regional Councils

Central government officials have proposed a significant restructuring of local governance, aiming to dissolve regional councils in favor of a board composed of district mayors and possibly commissioners. This plan, revealed late last year, seeks to streamline decision-making processes across New Zealand’s regions. Submissions on the proposal are due by March 15, 2024.

The chairwoman of the Otago Regional Council, Hilary Calvert, has expressed strong reservations about the government’s suggestion. She argues that the plan is fraught with complications, particularly the potential conflicts of interest for mayors who would serve on the new board. “They’ve got plenty to do, but they cannot serve their own area and then sell their area down the river by suggesting any sort of merger,” Calvert stated.

Calvert advocates for a more logical approach, proposing that the new governance structures be organized around natural catchment areas. She pointed out the absurdity of having different regional councils on either side of the Waitaki River, emphasizing the need for representatives who truly understand the unique interests of their regions without being compromised by conflicting responsibilities.

The current proposal aims to reduce the number of councils across the country. There are currently 11 regional councils, 5 unitary councils, and 67 territorial authorities. Calvert believes that a more effective solution would involve allowing the existing councils to complete their three-year terms before implementing any changes. “It’s by far the cheapest and most effective way to do it,” she noted.

In her view, a change board should be established to determine how to best reorganize both the South Island and the North Island into fewer councils. Estimates suggest that the government is aiming for a total of 30 to 35 councils across the country. The newly proposed board would ideally be composed of individuals who are well-versed in the distinct needs of their areas, making decisions that benefit the communities they represent.

Calvert also highlighted the challenges facing mayors who would be tasked with overseeing the new structure while managing their own districts. During a recent meeting, one mayor questioned the very function of the regional council, indicating a lack of understanding regarding its responsibilities. “It’s just bizarre,” Calvert remarked, suggesting that mayors are already overwhelmed by issues like the Three Waters reforms and should not be distracted by this new governance model.

Tomorrow’s meeting will provide an opportunity for councillors to voice their opinions on the government’s proposal. A full council meeting is scheduled for February 11, 2024, where a formal submission will be finalized. Calvert’s concerns reflect a broader apprehension among local leaders regarding the potential implications of these proposed changes on regional governance and the communities they serve.