New Zealand Police Mandate Breath Test Training After Falsification Scandal

New Zealand’s police force has mandated that all officers complete an online training module for alcohol breath testing. This decision follows an investigation into more than 120 police staff suspected of falsifying results from 30,000 alcohol breath tests. The issue came to light after a new algorithm was developed to analyze testing data, revealing discrepancies that the devices themselves could not detect.

A memo distributed to staff highlighted the “recent discovery” of inaccurately recorded breath tests, which has significantly impacted public trust in law enforcement. The memo stated, “Police is committed to restoring that trust and confidence.” The training module is now available and must be completed by December 4, 2023. It lasts approximately 15 minutes and covers essential topics such as proper device operation, data handling protocols, and the importance of accurate breath screening in maintaining road safety.

Details of the Investigation

Acting Deputy Commissioner Jill Rogers acknowledged the serious implications of the situation on public confidence in the police’s breath testing procedures. She emphasized the importance of this training in reinstating correct practices and ensuring that all officers understand their responsibilities, particularly as the busy summer period approaches.

Rogers explained that the falsified tests involved officers manipulating the testing devices either at the beginning or end of their shifts, leading to inflated numbers. “What these staff have done is… clicked the device more times than they have actually interacted with a motorist,” she noted. The algorithm identified these irregularities, revealing that some officers, particularly within dedicated road policing teams, were involved.

The investigation is ongoing, and although none of the implicated officers have been suspended, Rogers did not rule out the possibility of criminal charges against those who falsified a significant number of tests. “I can’t predict what’s going to come from those employment investigations… but if we were to identify criminal offending, then that’s what we would address,” she stated.

Response from Transport Authorities

The New Zealand Transport Agency (NZTA) was informed of the issue in September 2023. A spokesperson expressed serious concern, stating that drink-driving enforcement is crucial for road safety in New Zealand. They are closely monitoring the police’s handling of the situation and have requested further information as investigations continue.

Despite the issues raised, the NZTA also affirmed that increased enforcement levels have historically led to improved road safety outcomes. An independent evaluation of the Road Policing Investment Programme (RPIP) is currently underway, which will inform future targets and activities, ensuring alignment with international best practices.

This incident sheds light on the systemic issues within the police force’s operations, prompting immediate action to restore integrity and public trust. The police’s commitment to addressing these challenges reflects a broader accountability to the communities they serve, especially as the summer season approaches, a time often associated with increased road activity and risks.