Auckland Man Faces Trial for Alleged Modern-Day Slavery

An Auckland man, Moeaia Tuai, is currently on trial facing serious allegations of modern-day slavery and multiple sexual offenses. The 63-year-old stands accused of controlling two teenagers “as if they were his property,” forcing them to work while retaining their earnings. The trial commenced in the High Court in Auckland and is expected to last for five weeks.

During the proceedings, Chis Howard, the prosecutor, outlined the Crown’s case against Tuai, stating that he significantly deprived the victims of their liberty. According to Howard, Tuai restricted their freedom of movement, limited their communication, and dictated their social interactions. He allegedly exploited them for labor and retained their income, treating them as if they were property.

Tuai denies all charges, including two counts of dealing in slaves, two counts of rape, eight counts of indecent assault, six counts of sexual violation by unlawful connection, and assault with a statue and a broom. Ian Tucker, Tuai’s defense lawyer, argued that the complainants had fabricated their allegations and urged the jury to remain impartial until all evidence is presented.

The alleged incidents reportedly took place in Auckland and Melbourne between 2016 and 2023. In a detailed opening statement, Howard described how Tuai seized the teenagers’ passports and threatened to report them to immigration authorities if they attempted to escape. According to the court, the older youth managed to leave in 2020, while the female complainant, now an adult, left last year.

Evidence presented in court included Tuai’s diaries, which documented the employment of the young woman across various jobs in Auckland. Howard stated that she earned at least $78,000, although this figure is likely higher since she was initially paid in cash. He emphasized that Tuai took control of her income, claiming the rewards of her labor for himself.

Tuai allegedly exploited the young woman by confiscating her bank login details, passwords, and bank cards, even compelling her to take out a $7,000 bank loan. When she managed to escape, Tuai reportedly withdrew the remaining $800 from her account, leaving her with nothing but a lingering loan debt of $6,000.

The court heard further details about the conditions the young man endured while working for Tuai. He was initially employed at a relative’s boarding lodge, where he was forced to perform various tasks, including handyman work, waste collection, and cleaning. His workload ranged from 50 to 60 hours per week, for which he was compensated with only $100 to $150 weekly—far below New Zealand’s minimum wage.

Howard reiterated that Tuai maintained strict control over the victims, forbidding them from communicating with others or even with each other. He allegedly threatened the young woman with death if she revealed any details about the sexual assaults.

The trial will continue as the jury hears further evidence regarding these serious allegations, shedding light on the disturbing claims of exploitation and abuse.