Ockham Awards Reinstates AI-Created Book Covers for 2024

The New Zealand Book Awards Trust has reversed its decision regarding the eligibility of two books that feature artificial intelligence-designed covers. The titles, Angel Train by Elizabeth Smither and Obligate Carnivore by Stephanie Johnson, will now be reconsidered for the prestigious Ockham Awards after being disqualified last month.

Initially, these works had been ruled ineligible for the 2024 fiction prize, valued at $65,000, due to a violation of the newly implemented entry criteria that prohibits the use of AI in cover designs. This decision was met with considerable support from leading literary organizations in New Zealand, including the Publishers Association of New Zealand and the New Zealand Society of Authors.

Trust Chairperson Addresses Concerns

On Friday, Nicola Legat, chairperson of the New Zealand Book Awards Trust, announced the reversal in a statement. She reaffirmed the trust’s commitment to introducing the AI-related rule for the 2026 awards but acknowledged the unique circumstances surrounding the two authors’ entries.

Legat explained that the publisher, Quentin Wilson from Christchurch, had not fully understood the new regulations at the time of entry. “The two books in question have a complex entry history,” she stated, highlighting the need for clarity in future submissions. She emphasized the importance of ensuring that all entries are made with due diligence, acknowledging that in this case, the decision to disqualify the titles resulted in “collateral damage” to two accomplished authors.

Future Implications for the Awards

The trust has indicated that it will allow three additional publishers who have also submitted works with AI-designed covers the opportunity to resubmit their entries. The judges will now refocus their evaluations as they prepare for the longlist announcement on January 29, 2024. From a competitive pool of over 170 entries, 44 books will make it onto the longlist.

While the trust stands by its decision to introduce restrictions on AI-generated content, Legat noted that some publishers felt they had insufficient notice regarding the new rules. The trust has taken this feedback into account while maintaining its position on AI-authored text for future awards.

This development not only highlights the evolving landscape of the publishing industry but also raises questions about the role of technology in creative fields. As the Ockham Awards navigate these challenges, the trust remains committed to supporting authors and artists while ensuring a fair competition for all entries.