All Blacks Face Pressure for Change After Mixed 2025 Season

The All Blacks concluded their 2025 season with a record of ten wins and three losses, raising questions about the team’s direction under coach Scott Robertson. Despite achieving a respectable win-loss ratio, the team’s performance highlighted serious inconsistencies and a lack of progress, particularly in the context of significant tournaments like the Rugby Championship and the Grand Slam.

Robertson’s tenure, now in its second year, has not produced the anticipated results. The All Blacks failed to secure the Rugby Championship trophy and fell short in their attempt to achieve a Grand Slam for the first time in five opportunities. While many teams might envy a 10-3 record, closer scrutiny reveals that five of those victories came against teams deemed less competitive, such as a weakened French side and an underperforming Wallabies squad. This leaves a concerning 4-3 record against top-tier opponents, signaling an urgent need for a reevaluation within the team.

Challenges Ahead for Robertson

As the All Blacks navigate the mid-point of the World Cup cycle, the question arises: should alarm bells be ringing? Robertson faces a crossroads, needing to reconsider his strategies and personnel. Although he publicly claims the team has “turned the corner,” the reality suggests otherwise. If he is to maintain his position, he must address the evident shortcomings as he prepares for a challenging campaign ahead, which includes four road tests against a formidable South African team.

The coaching staff has already begun to shift, with Jason Holland departing, leaving gaps that need to be filled. Robertson has pledged a thorough review of the team’s performance and acknowledges the necessity for change. Considering the stakes, he may benefit from bringing in fresh perspectives to invigorate the coaching approach.

The playing roster is also under scrutiny. The introduction of nine new players this year, including promising talents like Fabian Holland and Simon Parker, indicates a move towards renewal. However, the performance of established players has raised concerns about their future in the squad.

Key Players Under Pressure

Several high-profile players may find themselves battling for their spots in the upcoming season.

Beauden Barrett, despite being one of the All Blacks’ most celebrated backs, is showing signs of decline. His recent performances, particularly against England, have raised doubts about his game management and ability to influence matches. With Richie Mo’unga returning, Barrett must rediscover his best form.

Another player facing uncertainty is Rieko Ioane, whose performances have waned significantly. His upcoming sabbatical with Leinster may be a critical period for rejuvenation, but if he fails to regain his form, he risks becoming an afterthought in the All Blacks’ future plans.

Sevu Reece is in a similar position. His contributions against lesser opponents have not translated into consistent performances against top-tier teams. As competition for wing positions increases, he must elevate his game to secure his place.

Additionally, Anton Lienert-Brown and Scott Barrett are also under pressure. Lienert-Brown’s age and injury issues have begun to hamper his effectiveness, while Barrett’s leadership has come under scrutiny. His performance as captain has raised questions about his ability to inspire and innovate during challenging moments.

Standout Performers and Future Prospects

Despite the team’s struggles, there were notable performances this season. Cam Roigard emerged as a standout player, showcasing remarkable consistency and resilience. His absence due to injury highlighted his value to the team, and his instinctive play has marked him as a key asset moving forward.

Newcomer Fabian Holland has been lauded for his impactful debut season. Coach Robertson praised Holland’s dedication and work ethic, recognizing him as a significant find for the team. His development, along with that of other emerging talents, could shape the All Blacks’ future strategy.

As the All Blacks prepare for the challenges of 2026, including the inaugural Nations Championship, the need for a comprehensive review and potential restructuring of both the coaching staff and player roster is imperative. The pressure is on Robertson to make the right decisions that could determine the trajectory of one of rugby’s most storied teams.