Holocaust Centre Critiques John Tamihere’s ‘Nazi Germany’ Remark

The Holocaust Centre of New Zealand has sharply criticized Te Pāti Māori president John Tamihere for his recent assertion that the New Zealand Government is “worse than Nazi Germany.” This statement was made during an appearance on The Bradbury Group podcast hosted by media commentator Martyn Bradbury. The remark has sparked significant backlash, with the Centre describing it as “harmful at worst” and a radicalization of political discourse.

Tamihere’s comments surfaced while discussing the Labour Party’s prospects for re-election in 2026. He was joined by Labour MP Arena Williams, where they addressed issues surrounding immunization rates within Māori communities. Tamihere criticized the Government’s approach, characterizing it as a “bully-boy mentality” and claimed that alternative economic views expressed by academics were being undermined. He went on to state, “This is worse than Nazi Germany, this is a fascist regime that has to be removed.”

In response, Giacomo Lichtner, deputy chairman of the Holocaust Centre, condemned Tamihere’s hyperbolic rhetoric. Lichtner stated that such comparisons trivialize the historical significance of the Holocaust and contribute to an unproductive political atmosphere. He emphasized that while political discourse is vital, it should not resort to extreme analogies that distort reality.

The Holocaust Centre aims to educate the public about the atrocities of the Holocaust and to promote a message of tolerance and understanding. Lichtner reiterated that comparisons to historical events such as the Holocaust should be approached with utmost care and respect. He indicated that Tamihere’s comments could potentially alienate those who have a deep connection to the history of the Holocaust.

Political analysts have noted that remarks like Tamihere’s often serve to intensify division rather than foster meaningful dialogue. This incident has reignited discussions about the standards of political discourse in New Zealand and the responsibility of public figures to engage in respectful and fact-based conversations.

As the political landscape in New Zealand continues to evolve, the Holocaust Centre’s condemnation serves as a reminder of the importance of historical context in political discussions. The Centre calls for a more measured approach to political critique, one that acknowledges the past while addressing present challenges.

The ongoing debate highlights a broader trend in political rhetoric, where extreme comparisons frequently emerge. As New Zealand approaches its next elections, citizens and leaders alike are encouraged to reflect on the implications of their words and the legacy they leave behind.