Tragic Tractor Incidents Prompt Safety Warnings in Farming

Two tragic incidents involving tractor use in December 2023 have led to urgent safety warnings from New Zealand’s coroners. The first victim, Melvin Patrick “Speedo” Robinson, a 77-year-old farmer from Golden Bay, died after being crushed under a vehicle he was attempting to lift using his tractor. His son, Brendon Robinson, expressed his shock at the unexpected nature of his father’s death, noting that he “could have died a thousand times” in various scenarios, but not like this.

On the afternoon of December 11, 2023, Robinson was found pinned beneath a car when the hoisting system he used—a set of front forks on his tractor—failed. He had been trying to remove wire caught around the car’s driveshaft, a vehicle he often used to train horses on the beach near Patons Rock. Tragically, moments before his death, he had been in good spirits and was advised by a friend to use a disc grinder for the task.

Coroner’s Warnings Highlight Safety Concerns

The Associate Coroner Stephen Burdes issued a stern warning following an investigation into Robinson’s death, cautioning against the dangerous practice of using tractors in ways they were not designed for. His findings echoed those of Coroner Ian Telford, who had made similar comments regarding another farmer’s death just days earlier. Telford’s remarks served as a reminder to the agricultural community to adhere strictly to the intended use of machinery.

Burdes emphasized the necessity for farmers to “resist any temptation” to use tractor forks or forklifts to lift vehicles while working underneath them. The coroner’s statement underscored a common but perilous practice in farming that has contributed to numerous accidents.

Robinson was well-known and respected within the Golden Bay community, having moved from Palmerston North in the early 1980s to pursue farming. His son recounted how Melvin was a vibrant personality, actively involved in local sports and horse racing. Brendon affectionately described his father as a “bit of a larrikin,” highlighting his love for life and the outdoors.

Investigations Reveal Fatal Decisions

The events leading to Robinson’s fatality unfolded quickly on that fateful day. After a neighbor grew concerned about the running tractor, he and a passing police officer checked on Robinson. They discovered the tractor still operational, with forks raised and the car positioned below, leading to the grim discovery of Robinson pinned underneath.

A post-mortem examination revealed that he died from crush injuries, particularly to his head and chest, suggesting traumatic asphyxiation as the cause of death. Investigators concluded that Robinson had connected a chain between the tractor’s front forks and the vehicle’s tow connector. The coroner noted that a critical metal strut likely snapped, causing the car to fall on him.

Brendon Robinson speculated that a failure in the chain could have contributed to the incident, acknowledging the inherent risks that farmers face daily. He reflected on the nature of farming, stating that while many farmers live on the edge, his father’s demise was particularly unexpected.

The farming sector in New Zealand has faced scrutiny over safety practices, with Federated Farmers acknowledging the unfortunate deaths of both Robinson and another farmer, Goodin, within such a short timeframe. In remarks to NZME, board member David Birkett highlighted the alarming statistic that agriculture accounted for approximately 40 percent of all reported workplace fatalities in New Zealand. He emphasized the need for farmers to take a moment to assess risks before engaging in new activities.

Birkett stated, “Accidents do happen, and while some might be a freak occurrence, there is always a chance for something to go wrong.” He urged a culture of safety within the farming community, encouraging workers to always prioritize caution and risk assessment.

As the farming community reflects on these tragic events, the focus remains on enhancing safety practices to prevent further loss of life. The messages from officials and community members are clear: vigilance and adherence to safe operating procedures are essential to protect those who work the land.